Test Cutting Assumptions
Moderators:Scott M. Rodell, PaulC
- ben hanawalt
- Rank: Frequent Contributor
- Posts:17
- Joined:Tue Sep 27, 2005 10:01 am
- Location:Los Montanos
- Contact:
- J HepworthYoung
- Rank: Chang San feng
- Posts:276
- Joined:Fri Jul 28, 2006 12:19 pm
- Location:Sacramento
- Contact:
I have used a few things to practice cutting. I have an Ontario Knife USMC machete that I have frequently taken camping and used to cut many things, ranging from dry firewood to soft green plants.
I have wondered if such practice would translate well with the Jian type swords.
I have owned the machete for many years and spent hours experimenting with different edges . it was after I became familair with the structure of a katana that I stopped sharpening the machete like a knife and put a more sword like edge on it. At that point I found I could cut a 2X4 in half with two blows, one from the left and one from the right and could cut the quince tree in my yard in a way that left very smooth attactive curfaces on the cut.
I also try cutting rose stems and find it very hard to get a nice clean cut. I can swipe at soft stem type plants like hops with my hand and often "cut" them in the same way one would with a fast moving stick, speed it the key there, but with a machete or my straight sword I found speed was not nearly as important as form. Last week I was putting a carbon steel ninja-to forward at an angle only 1-2 inches from the target and then turning at the waist (or hip) with only moderate speed. Not only did I find the sword cut right through the target material easily, thus confirming to my mind Mushasi's claim that a cutting stoke need not be fast, but I found that when I tried the same thing with my curved katana I could not get the cuts to work well and they were not clean. The edge of the ninja sword is not as smooth or as polished as the katana, I wonder if the straight blade and the presence of microserrations lend themselves to facilitate these slow horizontal cuts on soft targets? The katana is nearly 4 lbs however and the straight sword is under 2 lbs so I have more subtle control over the lighter blade.
I have a Hanwei Hsu sword for practicing, the one that had only a sharp point but no edge. Is it impractical to polish/sharpen it to have a cutting edge at least toward the last 1/3 of the blade near the tip where the harmonic node is located? I should like to have a sharp jian, though I don't mind waiting a few years to obtain one.
I have wondered if such practice would translate well with the Jian type swords.
I have owned the machete for many years and spent hours experimenting with different edges . it was after I became familair with the structure of a katana that I stopped sharpening the machete like a knife and put a more sword like edge on it. At that point I found I could cut a 2X4 in half with two blows, one from the left and one from the right and could cut the quince tree in my yard in a way that left very smooth attactive curfaces on the cut.
I also try cutting rose stems and find it very hard to get a nice clean cut. I can swipe at soft stem type plants like hops with my hand and often "cut" them in the same way one would with a fast moving stick, speed it the key there, but with a machete or my straight sword I found speed was not nearly as important as form. Last week I was putting a carbon steel ninja-to forward at an angle only 1-2 inches from the target and then turning at the waist (or hip) with only moderate speed. Not only did I find the sword cut right through the target material easily, thus confirming to my mind Mushasi's claim that a cutting stoke need not be fast, but I found that when I tried the same thing with my curved katana I could not get the cuts to work well and they were not clean. The edge of the ninja sword is not as smooth or as polished as the katana, I wonder if the straight blade and the presence of microserrations lend themselves to facilitate these slow horizontal cuts on soft targets? The katana is nearly 4 lbs however and the straight sword is under 2 lbs so I have more subtle control over the lighter blade.
I have a Hanwei Hsu sword for practicing, the one that had only a sharp point but no edge. Is it impractical to polish/sharpen it to have a cutting edge at least toward the last 1/3 of the blade near the tip where the harmonic node is located? I should like to have a sharp jian, though I don't mind waiting a few years to obtain one.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts:1364
- Joined:Wed Jan 28, 2004 4:50 pm
- Location:Virginia
- Contact:
J HepworthYoung wrote:I have used a few things to practice cutting. I have an Ontario Knife USMC machete... I have wondered if such practice would translate well with the Jian type swords...
Yes & No... some aspects of cutting are universal, such as the importance of the edge & cutting plane being parrallel; but obviously, there would not be so many different blade types if they all cut in the same manner. The important point is to understand how different blade types work, what are the strengths & weaknesses of each, then select the right one for the job at hand. It is also useful to undestand these qualities so that one understands the best way to engage each weapon type & how that weapon is likely to be wielded against one.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts:1364
- Joined:Wed Jan 28, 2004 4:50 pm
- Location:Virginia
- Contact:
Test Cutting with Jian & Dao Video
Here's what I was talking about when I first started this thread...
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... dell&hl=en
As you can see in this video, both the straight bladed jian & curved dao are cutting the same targets with equal efficiency. Sure, one could a thicker target with a two-handed cut, but what point would there be in cutting a target that is thicker than a human is in respect to historical swordsmanship?
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... dell&hl=en
As you can see in this video, both the straight bladed jian & curved dao are cutting the same targets with equal efficiency. Sure, one could a thicker target with a two-handed cut, but what point would there be in cutting a target that is thicker than a human is in respect to historical swordsmanship?
-
- Rank: Chang San feng
- Posts:339
- Joined:Wed Jun 30, 2004 10:17 am
- Location:maplewood NJ
- Contact:
B.Ko wrote: Even with aligned hit, the blade began to take on a curve like a saber. I suspect heat treatment is an issue.
Ben Ko
Scott, can you comment on this? I thought a sword would not bend in the same plane as the edge. I recently found an antique seven star duan jian with a saber like curve to the blade. I though this must be intentional as it is impossible (or at least very difficult) to bend a blade in that direction. Was I wrong?
Josh
hidup itu silat, silat itu hidup
-Suhu
-Suhu
- J HepworthYoung
- Rank: Chang San feng
- Posts:276
- Joined:Fri Jul 28, 2006 12:19 pm
- Location:Sacramento
- Contact:
Re: Test Cutting with Jian & Dao Video
That video is very nice. What make of Jian did you employ?Scott M. Rodell wrote:Here's what I was talking about when I first started this thread...
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid ... dell&hl=en
As you can see in this video, both the straight bladed jian & curved dao are cutting the same targets with equal efficiency. Sure, one could a thicker target with a two-handed cut, but what point would there be in cutting a target that is thicker than a human is in respect to historical swordsmanship?
-
- Site Admin
- Posts:1364
- Joined:Wed Jan 28, 2004 4:50 pm
- Location:Virginia
- Contact:
Re: Test Cutting with Jian & Dao Video
J HepworthYoung wrote:... very nice. What make of Jian... ?
It is a Huanuo Royal Peony Jian with a sanmai blade, see:
http://www.sevenstarstrading.com/huanuo ... =goldpeony
-
- Site Admin
- Posts:1364
- Joined:Wed Jan 28, 2004 4:50 pm
- Location:Virginia
- Contact:
Re: Test Cutting Assumptions
Concerning the cutting efficiency of straight vs. curved bladesScott M. Rodell wrote:... the notion that there is a great difference in effective cutting ability between a straight blade and a curved blade is false....
see- Japanese Katana Vs European Broadsword
"The European sword, even with it blunted edge, did just as good a job (of cutting)."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fxYvwEnK ... re=related